Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stout Yeoman's avatar

Unlike other interventions in the Middle East this is not a war the US initiated. It is Israel fighting for its survival. As Natasha Hausdorf said, one can take the view that Isreal should not have been created, but like a pregnancy one can debate whether the child should be born or terminated but only up to delivery. After it is born it has the right to live.

Israel has suffered intifadas with over 1000 suicide bombings until they built the wall along the West Bank, and endless rockets from Lebanon and Gaza, the products of the death cult that is Iran. 7th October, that gleeful savagery, was their enough is enough point. The US has merely delivered the bunker buster bombs that show the US is serious about Iran not having nuclear bombs, but otherwise the war is between Israel and Iran.

Anyone who thinks that the Iranian mullahs who believe destroying Israel will bring the return of the twelfth imman can be reasoned with is as deluded as Obama and Biden. Trump has badly mishandled the messaging but support for Israel is not misplaced.

As to the fear porn about a wider middle east conflagration, other Arab states want to see Iran (and trouble making Palestinians) reigned in. No Arab state is taking Palestinain 'refugees' - they learnt their lesson about that long ago adn none want to see Iran get the bomb. There may be sleeper cells but then there is now an incentive to round them up.

Yes, there may be unforeseen consequences. Whether they are worse than the foreseen one of Iran getting the bomb remains to be seen. Israel is quite clear about what it sees.

Expand full comment
Andrew Marsh's avatar

2026 will mark the 250th anniversary of the American independence from the United Kingdom.

As per usual, all kinds of voices from the modern USA have been putting all sorts of poison out about the UK over the past 12 months. It's sooo USA.

Let's review the number of wars the USA has won since 1945: Zero.

Let's review the number of regime changes funded by the USA since 1945, with successful democracy: Zero.

One USA commentator recently stated the USA is a republic and is not cut out for empire.

Will the USA wake up?

Our empire is gone, but there is something about us the USA missed.

The events around 1948 are telling - the UK planned independence of Palestine by 1951 / 1952, but lest our American friends forget, every single item supplied from 1938-1946 was paid for. As usual the UK was out of cash, in part thanks to the multiple loans - so elements in the USA forced the UK to pull forward independence and to enable the formation of Israel, complete with multi-nation sing-a-long vocals.

The UK warned against this, the USA threatened to cut off loans. That's blackmail.

Like us or not, the UK had an ability to manage independence of another nation better than most.

The USA has never done this on behalf of another nation.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts